By Roberto Gomes, Prime Capital Report | Updated October 2026
One speeding ticket typically raises car insurance by about 22% to 25%, or roughly $500 to $600 a year, and the surcharge usually lasts about three years. ValuePenguin’s June 2026 analysis puts the average speeding ticket insurance increase at 24%, or $50 a month for full coverage. LendingTree’s nationwide study found 22.7%, or $524.74 more a year, for a ticket 11 to 15 mph over the limit.
The real number depends more on your insurer and state than on the ticket itself. Below we break down the increase by speed, insurer and state, explain points and traffic school, compare speeding with reckless driving and red-light tickets, and list the cheapest insurers after a ticket. Every figure is linked to its source.
Key takeaways
- Average increase: 24% after a first ticket, about $50 a month (ValuePenguin, June 2026); 22.7% or $524.74 a year (LendingTree).
- Insurer matters most: State Farm raised rates 22% and USAA 20%, while GEICO raised them 59% and Nationwide 68% (CarInsurance.com, Aug 2026).
- State matters too: California shows the largest increase (44%) and New York the smallest (11%) in ValuePenguin’s data.
- How long it lasts: Around three years for most insurers; rates often return to normal in year four (ValuePenguin).
- Cheapest after a ticket: Travelers at $177 a month and State Farm at $189 for full coverage (NerdWallet, Oct 2026).
- Best fix: Traffic school or a defensive driving course can keep a ticket off your insurance record in some states, and shopping at renewal can erase most of the surcharge.
How much does a speeding ticket raise car insurance on average?
Most major studies put a first ticket at roughly a fifth to a quarter of the typical premium; dollar figures differ because each uses a different driver profile and coverage level.
- ValuePenguin (updated June 30, 2026): rates rise 24% after a first ticket, or about $50 a month for full coverage (source).
- LendingTree (published November 2025, rate data pulled October 2025): 22.7%, or $524.74 a year ($43.73 a month), adding up to $1,574.22 over three years (source).
- CarInsurance.com (updated August 14, 2026): 38% on average at the next renewal, based on 40-year-old drivers with 100/300/100 limits (source).
- The Zebra (updated October 2026): drivers with a ticket for 16 to 20 mph over pay an average of $2,934 a year, versus $2,323 with a clean record (source). The Zebra also notes the average speeding fine is about $150, while the insurance penalty runs $588 or more a year for three years, or more than $1,600 in total.
The fine is paid once; the surcharge repeats at every renewal. To see how your premium compares before a ticket, our 2026 US car insurance cost report lays out national and state averages.
Younger drivers pay the most in dollars
The percentage increase is similar across ages, but higher base premiums make the dollar hit much larger for young drivers. LendingTree found a 20-year-old’s premium rises by $1,183.67 a year after a ticket (28.9%), compared with $548.09 for a driver in their 60s (LendingTree). If you are under 25, see our guide to the cheapest car insurance for young drivers in 2026.
Increase by how many mph over the limit
How fast you were going matters, but for most ordinary tickets it matters less than people expect. The bigger jumps come when speed crosses into a “major” violation or reckless driving.
| Speed over the limit | Average annual full coverage rate | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| 1–10 mph over | $3,390 | $283 |
| 11–29 mph over | $3,547 | $296 |
| 30+ mph over | $3,750 | $313 |
Source: CarInsurance.com, August 2026 (Quadrant Information Services data).
In CarInsurance.com’s data, a ticket for 30+ mph over costs about $360 a year more than a 1–10 mph ticket (our calculation from the table above). ValuePenguin’s Pennsylvania analysis shows an even flatter curve: $2,696 a year for a ticket under 10 mph over, $2,703 for 11–20 mph over, and $2,733 for 21–25 mph over (ValuePenguin). Insurers mostly price the fact that you have a ticket; speed shows up more in the fine and license points.
North Carolina: the one state that publishes the exact surcharge
North Carolina sets insurance surcharges by law through its Safe Driver Incentive Plan (SDIP), so speed bands translate directly into a percentage increase. According to the NC Department of Insurance:
- 1 point (40% increase): speeding 10 mph or less over a limit under 55 mph.
- 2 points (55% increase): speeding more than 10 mph over at a total speed above 55 and below 76 mph, or 10 mph or less over in a 55+ mph zone.
- 4 points (90% increase): speeding over 75 mph where the limit is under 70, or over 80 mph where the limit is 70 or higher; reckless driving is also 4 points.
- 10 points (260% increase): speeding to elude arrest.
There is an important exception: a ticket for 10 mph or less over the limit (outside a school zone) carries no insurance points unless the driver has another moving violation in the five years before the renewal, for convictions on or after July 1, 2025 (NCDOI).
Speeding ticket insurance increase by insurer
This is where the biggest differences are. The same driver with the same ticket can see a 20% increase at one company and a 68% increase at another.
| Insurer | Before ticket | After ticket | $ increase | % increase |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| USAA* | $1,628 | $1,955 | $327 | 20% |
| State Farm | $2,875 | $3,497 | $622 | 22% |
| Allstate | $3,159 | $4,025 | $866 | 27% |
| Progressive | $2,569 | $3,436 | $867 | 34% |
| Farmers | $3,207 | $4,431 | $1,224 | 38% |
| Travelers | $1,962 | $2,801 | $839 | 43% |
| Amica | $2,769 | $4,102 | $1,333 | 48% |
| GEICO | $2,159 | $3,426 | $1,267 | 59% |
| Nationwide | $2,524 | $4,247 | $1,723 | 68% |
Average annual full coverage rates. *USAA is available only to military members and their families. Source: CarInsurance.com, August 2026.
ValuePenguin’s 2026 data points the same way: State Farm raises rates the least among major insurers for a first ticket, about 9%, or roughly $18 a month (ValuePenguin). A small percentage increase doesn’t always mean the lowest bill: Travelers adds 43% here but still ranks among the cheapest after a ticket because it starts from a lower base.
Speeding ticket insurance increase by state
State rules, claim costs and regulation all change how hard a ticket hits. The table below pulls several large states from two 2026 data sets and one late-2025 study. Because each uses a different driver profile, compare states within a column, not across columns.
| State | ValuePenguin % increase (2026) | LendingTree % increase (11–15 mph) | LendingTree $ increase per year | CarInsurance.com % increase (2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | 44% | 42.0% | $1,004.73 | 52% |
| Arizona | 30% | 28.1% | $1,071.41 | 42% |
| Michigan | 17% | 35.8% | $881.60 | 72% |
| North Carolina | 39% | 13.4% | $390.09 | 47% |
| Texas | 20% | 12.5% | $329.13 | 52% |
| Florida | 13% | 12.4% | $421.43 | 34% |
| Georgia | 15% | 16.2% | $435.57 | 33% |
| Illinois | 24% | 27.8% | $586.16 | 45% |
| Pennsylvania | 21% | 26.6% | $566.50 | 19% |
| New York | 11% | 13.4% | $390.09 | 30% |
Sources: ValuePenguin (June 2026); LendingTree (Quadrant data pulled Oct. 3, 2025); CarInsurance.com (August 2026).
A few patterns stand out:
- California is consistently near the top. ValuePenguin ranks it first at 44%, and LendingTree also ranks it first at 42.0%.
- Arizona and California carry the biggest dollar penalties. They are the only states where LendingTree measured an average increase above $1,000 a year.
- Vermont is the cheapest place to get a ticket in dollar terms: $225.40 a year in LendingTree’s study.
For state-by-state premiums before any violation, see our US car insurance by state guide.
How long does a speeding ticket affect your insurance?
For most drivers, about three years. ValuePenguin found that many insurers keep the full increase for the first two years, lower it by about 8% in the third year, and return to normal in year four; Erie, Progressive, State Farm, Travelers and USAA follow this pattern, while GEICO and Nationwide lower rates gradually each year (ValuePenguin). Its Pennsylvania sample shows the monthly cost falling from $225 six months after a ticket to $192 at three years.
The Zebra adds that insurers typically consider violations for three years, but drivers usually don’t qualify for “good driver” discounts until they’ve been violation-free for five years (The Zebra).
How long the ticket stays on your driving record is set by the state, and it can differ from how long your insurer uses it:
- California: traffic convictions and collisions stay on your record for 36 months or longer, depending on the type (California DMV).
- Virginia: a speeding ticket stays on your record for five years (ValuePenguin).
- New York: points stop counting toward suspension after 24 months, but they remain on your record as long as the conviction does and “may be used by your insurance company to increase premiums” (NY DMV).
- North Carolina: the SDIP surcharge for most convictions applies for three policy years (NCDOI).
Your rate also won’t change the day you get the ticket. Insurers check your record at renewal, so the increase shows up on your next renewal offer (ValuePenguin).
Multiple tickets stack up fast
ValuePenguin found that one ticket raises rates about 24%, two tickets about 45%, and three tickets about 60% compared with a clean record (ValuePenguin). Enough violations can also trigger a license suspension and, in many states, an SR-22 filing requirement.
How points systems work
Most states put points on your license for moving violations. LendingTree notes that most states with a points system add two to four points for speeding 10 to 15 mph over, and that Hawaii, Kansas, Louisiana, Minnesota, Mississippi, Oregon, Rhode Island, Texas, Washington and Wyoming don’t use point systems (LendingTree).
DMV points decide license suspensions; insurance surcharges are set by each insurer from your driving record. As the NY DMV puts it, insurance companies “have their own point systems” (NY DMV).
New York assigns speeding points by mph over the limit (NY DMV):
- 1–10 mph over: 3 points
- 11–20 mph over: 4 points
- 21–30 mph over: 6 points
- 31–40 mph over: 8 points
- More than 40 mph over: 11 points
- Speeding in a work zone: 8 points; reckless driving: 5 points
In New York, 11 points in 24 months can lead to a suspension, and 6 or more points in 18 months triggers a Driver Responsibility Assessment fee (NY DMV). California can suspend an adult license at 4 points in 12 months, 6 in 24 months, or 8 in 36 months (California DMV).
Traffic school and defensive driving: can they stop the increase?
Sometimes, and it is the most effective step where allowed. Rules vary by state:
- California: for a one-point violation, a judge may let you attend traffic violator school so the citation is not reported to your insurance company (it stays on your driving record). You can do this once in any 18-month period (California DMV).
- Texas: eligible drivers can have a ticket dismissed by completing a driving safety course, but not more than once in 12 months, and not for speeding 25 mph or more over the limit or at 95 mph or more. A charge dismissed this way may not be part of your driving record, and an insurer may not raise your premium because you took the course or had the charge dismissed (Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 45.0511, 2023 text). Texas reorganized these court procedures effective January 1, 2025, so confirm current eligibility on your citation or with the court.
- New York: a DMV-approved Point and Insurance Reduction Program (PIRP) course doesn’t remove the ticket, but it saves 10% on liability and collision premiums and offsets 4 points for suspension purposes (NY DMV).
ValuePenguin cautions that reducing license points doesn’t always lower your insurance, because insurers can rate you on your driving record rather than your point total (ValuePenguin). Ask your court whether completion keeps the conviction off your insurance record, not just off your point count.
Speeding vs. reckless driving, red lights and other violations
A routine speeding ticket sits in the middle of the pack. Reckless driving, racing and DUI are in a different league.
| Violation | Average annual premium | Increase vs. clean record |
|---|---|---|
| Clean record | $2,323 | — |
| Failure to wear a seat belt | $2,712 | +17% |
| Cell phone violation | $2,861 | +23% |
| Failure to stop at a red light | $2,885 | +24% |
| Speeding in a school zone | $2,887 | +24% |
| Speeding 16–20 mph over | $2,934 | +26% |
| Driving with a suspended license | $4,243 | +83% |
| Reckless driving | $4,316 | +86% |
| Racing | $4,454 | +92% |
| DUI | $4,575 | +97% |
| Hit and run | $4,608 | +98% |
Premiums from The Zebra (October 2025 rate analysis, updated October 2026). Percentages are our calculation from The Zebra’s premiums; The Zebra’s own write-up cites reckless driving at +87%, racing at +93% and DUI at +98%.
A red-light ticket costs about the same as a typical speeding ticket here, but a reckless driving charge roughly triples the penalty. North Carolina’s law shows the same jump: an ordinary speeding ticket carries a 40% or 55% surcharge, while reckless driving carries 90% (NCDOI). For the most serious category, see our guide to car insurance after a DUI.
Cheapest car insurance companies after a speeding ticket
NerdWallet’s October 2026 analysis of a 35-year-old driver with one speeding ticket found these median full coverage rates among large insurers (NerdWallet):
- Travelers: $2,127 a year ($177 a month), the cheapest large insurer for drivers with a ticket
- State Farm: $2,266 a year ($189 a month)
- GEICO: $2,751 a year ($229 a month)
- Progressive: $3,007 a year ($251 a month)
- USAA: $1,924 a year ($160 a month), for military families and veterans only
For minimum (liability-only) coverage, GEICO was cheapest in the same analysis at $656 a year, or $55 a month. ValuePenguin’s 2026 data names American Family as the cheapest major insurer after a ticket at $189 a month, and notes that Erie, Auto-Owners and USAA can be even cheaper where available (ValuePenguin).
How to pay less after a ticket
- Ask about traffic school or a driving safety course before you pay the ticket. In California and Texas, this can keep the ticket away from your insurer entirely.
- Shop at renewal, not right away. The ticket won’t affect your rate until your policy renews, so compare quotes when your renewal offer arrives (ValuePenguin). Our guide on how to compare car insurance quotes walks through the process.
- Target insurers with small surcharges. State Farm and USAA had the smallest increases in CarInsurance.com’s data; Travelers and State Farm had the lowest bills in NerdWallet’s.
- Raise your collision deductible. LendingTree’s licensed agent recommends this as a way to cut rates whether or not you have a ticket (LendingTree).
- Avoid a second violation. A second ticket nearly doubles the surcharge, from 24% to 45% (ValuePenguin).
FAQ
How much does insurance go up after one speeding ticket?
About 24% on average, or roughly $50 a month for full coverage, according to ValuePenguin’s 2026 data. LendingTree measured 22.7%, or $524.74 a year, for a ticket 11 to 15 mph over.
Which insurer raises rates the least after a speeding ticket?
State Farm among the large national insurers: about 9% in ValuePenguin’s 2026 data and 22% in CarInsurance.com’s. USAA, available only to military families, raised rates 20% in CarInsurance.com’s analysis.
How long does a speeding ticket affect car insurance?
Usually about three years. Many insurers keep the full increase for two years, reduce it in the third and return to normal in year four. Good-driver discounts may take five violation-free years to come back.
Does going 30 mph over raise insurance more than 10 mph over?
Yes, but less than most people expect. CarInsurance.com’s 2026 data shows $3,390 a year for a 1–10 mph ticket versus $3,750 for 30+ mph over. The bigger risk at high speed is a reckless driving charge, which pushes the increase to roughly 86% to 87% in The Zebra’s data.
Is a red-light ticket better or worse than a speeding ticket for insurance?
About the same. The Zebra’s data shows an average premium of $2,885 after a red-light ticket and $2,934 after a ticket for 16–20 mph over, against $2,323 with a clean record.
Can traffic school keep a speeding ticket off my insurance?
In some states. California lets eligible drivers with a one-point ticket attend traffic violator school so the citation isn’t reported to their insurer, once every 18 months. Texas allows a driving safety course dismissal once every 12 months for tickets under 25 mph over.
When will my insurance go up after a speeding ticket?
At your next renewal. Insurers check your driving record before renewing, so you won’t see the increase mid-policy. That’s also the best time to compare quotes.
What is the cheapest car insurance after a speeding ticket?
Travelers, at $177 a month for full coverage, was the cheapest large insurer in NerdWallet’s October 2026 analysis, followed by State Farm at $189. USAA was cheaper at $160 for those who qualify.
Related guides
Sources
- ValuePenguin, “Car Insurance Rate Increases with a Speeding Ticket in 2026,” updated June 30, 2026: valuepenguin.com
- LendingTree, “Across US, Speeding Tickets Drive Up Insurance Costs by Over $500 a Year,” November 5, 2025: lendingtree.com
- CarInsurance.com, “How much does insurance go up after a speeding ticket?,” updated August 14, 2026: carinsurance.com
- NerdWallet, “Cheap Car Insurance Companies” (October 2026 analysis): nerdwallet.com
- The Zebra, “This One Traffic Ticket Can Double Your Insurance Rates,” updated October 20, 2026: thezebra.com
- North Carolina Department of Insurance, “Safe Driver Incentive Plan”: ncdoi.gov
- New York State DMV, “The New York State Driver Point System”: dmv.ny.gov
- California DMV, California Driver’s Handbook, Section 7: dmv.ca.gov
- Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 45.0511 (2023 text), via Justia: law.justia.com
More guides from Prime Capital Report
Written by
Roberto Gomes, Founder and Editor
Roberto researches insurance and personal finance in the United States and Canada from insurers' policy documents, regulator data and public rate filings. He is not a licensed agent or adviser. How we research.
Pingback: How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident? (2026)